Elon Musk’s cost-cutting and fraud-finding apparatus, the Department of Government Efficiency, came out swinging in recent days.
The result? Two stunning strikeouts.
A series of announcements by DOGE as well as claims by Musk and President Donald Trump about the agency’s efforts have crumbled under scrutiny even as they’re broadly repeated by conservative pundits, sympathetic media and the White House.
Two of the most notable claims — around Social Security fraud and $8 billion savings found in a Department of Homeland Security contract — have been debunked. Meanwhile, Trump’s agenda is set to add to the federal government’s deficit well in excess of what DOGE is cutting.
“It’s amateur hour in their federal government,” said Martin O’Malley, the former Maryland governor who ran the Social Security Administration under President Joe Biden. “There’s unelected people that are being given powers to go through and rummage through our personal data for reasons that nobody can quite figure out yet. It’s not for efficiency.”
Cutting government waste and hunting for fraud are perennially popular topics for politicians across the political spectrum. Federal agencies each have their own internal watchdogs — known as inspectors general — meant to hunt for misuse of taxpayer dollars. More than a dozen of them have been fired by the Trump administration.
In their place, DOGE has worked to make sweeping cuts, most of which appear to be focused more on Trump’s politics than anything else, and many of which experts warn could have unintended consequences.
“They’re throwing out the baby with the bathwater,” said Elaine Kamarck, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution who oversaw an eight-year effort to cut government spending and waste under President Bill Clinton.
These cuts are “going to blow up in their face,” she said, warning that fired staffers could undermine the United States’ ability to handle a crisis in national security, food safety, pandemics or aviation.
While sweeping cuts in the private sector — and particularly Silicon Valley — may be celebrated, government services can be life and death, she said.
“You take down Medicare payment system, you take down Social Security checks, you take down food inspections, OK? That kills people,” she said.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment.
DOGE’s cuts, as illustrated through the “receipts” posted online Monday, run the gamut across the U.S. government, albeit they appear to hew particularly to Trump’s politics — particularly opposition to diversity initiatives and media outlets. The more than 1,000 listed cuts represent a fraction of the $55 billion in savings DOGE says it has achieved in about a month of work, according to its website.
The list includes a hodgepodge of canceled media subscriptions, contracts and leases, and quite a few noticeable errors. One line item in DOGE’s receipts claimed $8 billion savings found in a Department of Homeland Security contract, when the contract was for $8 million. The receipts seemed to undermine DOGE’s own rhetoric, too. One of the DOGE wins from earlier in the month — a $57,000 contract in Sri Lanka focused on climate change mitigation that DOGE canceled — saves taxpayers nothing, the receipts note.
The bulk of the savings listed in the receipts was due to the closure of the United States Agency for International Development, which is embroiled in litigation over the legality of its closure. USAID accounted for about 1.2% of the overall U.S. budget.
“It’s an open question whether or not it’s legal to make some of these actions,” said Josh Sewell, director of research and policy at Taxpayers for Common Sense, a nonpartisan group advocating against government waste.
Musk has acknowledged that his team will make mistakes and correct them.
“Nobody’s going to bat a thousand,” he said during a White House news conference this month. “We will make mistakes, but we’ll act quickly to correct any mistakes.”
